Dissertation Replication Materials
Flood Risk Information, Floodplain Map Updates, and Property Values in Cook County, Illinois
Overview
This website provides supporting tables, figures, code notes, and documentation for my dissertation research on flood risk information and residential property values in Cook County, Illinois. It also includes supplementary and exploratory analyses beyond the dissertation.
The dissertation examines how housing markets respond to different forms of flood risk information, including FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Map updates and non-governmental flood risk information from First Street Foundation Flood Factor scores.
The materials hosted here are intended to make the dissertation analysis more transparent, reproducible, and easier to navigate.
This page provides a stable index to the additional materials referenced throughout the dissertation, Risk Perception and Real Estate Values in Cook County, Illinois. Items are listed in the order in which they appear in the dissertation so readers can locate the relevant supporting material using the printed page number.
The dissertation links to this landing page rather than directly to individual files. The links below can therefore be updated as the website changes without creating stale links in the dissertation itself.
The dissertation directs readers to the online repository for replication code, supplemental analyses, extended tables and figures, documentation, and additional methodological details.
This page should serve as the main guide to the repository and include:
- a description of each major data source;
- a diagram of the data-processing workflow;
- an explanation of the repository’s folder structure;
- links to the Question 1 and Question 2 materials;
- instructions for reproducing tables and figures; and
- a list of supplemental analyses not included in the dissertation document.
Research Questions
Research Question 1
How do residential property values respond when FEMA floodplain maps are updated and properties are added to or removed from the Special Flood Hazard Area?
This portion of the analysis focuses on FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Map updates, including preliminary and effective floodplain designations.
Research Question 2
How do residential property values respond to the public availability of First Street Foundation Flood Factor scores?
This portion of the analysis examines whether properties with higher Flood Factor scores sold for less after this information became publicly available, and whether those effects differed by existing FEMA floodplain status and region within Cook County.
Website Contents
The pages below organize the main tables, figures, and supporting analyses.
| Navigation Section | Page | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Website Info | Website Info | Landing page for the dissertation replication materials website. |
| Background Info | Background Info | Descriptive statistics and background information for the Cook County dissertation data. |
| Q1: FEMA FIRM Info | Q1: FEMA FIRM Tables | Main tables and supporting results for the FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Map update analysis. |
| Q2: Flood Factor Info | Q2: Flood Factor Marginal Effects | Main marginal effects tables and supporting results for the First Street Flood Factor analysis. |
| Q2: Flood Factor Info | Flood Factor Variable Checks | Robustness checks comparing binary, ordinal, and continuous Flood Factor variables in model specifications. |
| Additional Details | File Information | Notes on files, outputs, and supporting materials included in the website. |
Page numbers refer to the printed dissertation page numbers, not the PDF viewer’s page count.
Find supporting material by dissertation page
| Dissertation page | Supporting material | Description |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | FEMA flood-zone and Flood Factor coverage | Data, calculations, and code supporting the comparison between FEMA-designated SFHAs and First Street major-risk properties. |
| 22 | Replication materials and methods overview | Repository map, supporting outputs, data dependencies, and workflow. |
| 35 | Question 1 research-design assumptions | Parallel trends, event studies, placebo tests, and functional-form diagnostics for the FEMA map analysis. |
| 56 | Alternative definitions of flood exposure | Models comparing building and parcel intersections with the SFHA and 1-in-500-year floodplain. |
| 62 | Question 1 additional robustness checks | Spatial buffers, spillover exclusions, and alternative geographic time controls. |
| 69 | Question 2 research-design assumptions | Parallel-trend visualizations, slope tests, functional-form checks, and placebo-event results for the Flood Factor analysis. |
| 77 | Full Question 2 regression coefficients | Unaggregated coefficients underlying the reported marginal effects. |
| 111 | Reproducibility and computational workflow | Code, data-source instructions, R and Quarto files, pipelines, and replication guidance. |
Page 2: FEMA flood-zone and Flood Factor coverage
The supporting page explains the source files and the numerator and denominator in the existing Flood Factor calculation. It also identifies what remains to be verified before reproducing the exact FEMA-versus-First-Street percentages in the dissertation.
Page 22: Replication materials and methods overview
The dissertation promises a guide to the data, code, supplemental results, and methodology. The guide below maps each dissertation reference to its source and explains the distinction between existing saved outputs and a verified clean rebuild.
Page 35: Question 1 research-design assumptions
Page 35 directs readers to Appendix A (printed pages 91-99) for the Q1 difference-in-differences assumptions. The supporting sections below explain the existing event studies and placebo tests, assemble supplementary regional and transformation comparisons, and display saved distributional diagnostics with their specification history.
- Addition event study and joint pretrend test.
- Removal event study and joint pretrend test.
- Placebo-treatment tests: move the preliminary date two years earlier and restrict sales to before the actual date.
- Outcome transformations: compare levels, logs, inverse price, and inverse hyperbolic sine on common pretreatment samples.
- Saved distributional parallel-trends diagnostics: display the historical results and distinguish their samples and specifications.
- Conditional parallel trends and regional controls: compare common year effects with triad-by-year effects.
Page 56: Alternative definitions of flood exposure
The dissertation refers to Tables XIII and XIV for alternative spatial definitions. The existing Q1 page displays the saved grids for building versus parcel exposure, SFHA versus 1-in-500-year exposure, and preliminary versus effective timing. It now also includes a separately labeled inventory of treated observations in the current input datasets.
Page 62: Question 1 additional robustness checks
Section 5.4.9 of the dissertation (printed pages 61-62) examines whether the Q1 FEMA map results depend on the choice of nearby comparison properties or on controls for local housing-market changes. The supporting page contains the existing model tables, with explanations of the samples and fixed effects used.
- Properties within 300 meters of an SFHA: restrict the estimation sample to the existing GIS proximity list.
- Spatial spillover exclusion: exclude nearby properties without a recorded SFHA transition, retaining properties that were ever added or removed.
- Year-by-municipality controls: allow annual housing-market conditions to differ across municipalities within the nearby sample.
- Year-by-township controls: show the nearby-sample models, followed by a comparison using the full prepared sample.
- Year-by-FIRM-panel controls: allow annual conditions to differ across FIRM panels within the nearby sample.
Page 69: Question 2 research-design assumptions
Appendix B is supported by saved trend figures, existing slope and placebo tests, and historical distributional diagnostics. The linked explanations identify differences in samples and clarify what each diagnostic can establish.
Page 77: Full Question 2 regression coefficients
Appendix C’s supporting section displays the saved main-model coefficients before marginal-effect aggregation, including terms omitted from the formatted summary and a separate list of collinear terms. It explains the construction of subgroup contrasts and identifies a saved-model/current-code version discrepancy that still requires reconciliation with the dissertation.
Page 111: Reproducibility and computational workflow
The workflow guide documents software, input sources, analysis order, output locations, and rendering instructions. It distinguishes the available saved materials from unresolved requirements for rebuilding the dissertation from a clean checkout.
Data Sources
The analysis combines several property, flood risk, and spatial data sources, including:
- Cook County residential property sales data
- Cook County parcel data
- FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer data
- FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Map panel information
- Microsoft building footprint data
- First Street Foundation Flood Factor data
Some source data may not be redistributed directly through this website because of file size. Where direct redistribution is not possible, this site documents the relevant data source, processing steps, and derived variables used in the analysis.
Spatial data and data cleaning/merging largely take place in the _targets.R file. Models and exploration are done in the .qmd files.
Repository Structure
The repository and workflow guide describes the actual data, script, output, and website folders. The file inventory provides additional detail, including historical files.